Food With Legs Rotating Header Image

How do you like them apples?

The last two weeks of August and the first two of September are, in my opinion, the most interesting time to be at the cottage in Ontario.  The lake is at its warmest, the mosquitoes have gone, the nights are cool enough to actually sleep and hot days are now a welcome surprise.  Best of all, my favourite wild produce is finally ripe enough to eat.

Apples picked from a neighbours tree

Apples picked from a neighbour's tree

Picking apples in an orchard sounds like fun–I’ve never done it–but not really that much different than visiting a farmers’ market.  The fruit is fresher and you’re outside but where is the challenge?  The varieties are known and more often than not the apples are sprayed with something and grow on dwarf trees that are pruned to make the apples as accessible as possible.  Consider this Sunday afternoon in contrast: I was out walking on an ATV trail that cuts through the middle of a pasture that hasn’t seen a cow in fifty years.  No buildings, power lines, or roads in sight I was surrounded by nothing but grass, wildflowers, and the occasional clump of trees.  Walking on this track–to my chagrin google maps has somehow managed to detect it and marked it as a road–one gets to a point where the view is dominated by a haphazard-looking oak tree surrounded by a clump of smaller trees and assorted bushes.  Every time I walk this track my attention is always diverted by the oak tree’s peculiar shape–it has probably lost a major branch or two on the track-side –for long enough that its neighbours remain unnoticed until I’m almost right on top of them.  At this time of year one of these trees has vibrant spots of red interspersed amongst its coat of green leaves.  An apple tree, of course.

An apple tree growing unattended in the middle of a field

An apple tree growing unattended in the middle of a field

The story behind this tree is a bit of a mystery to me.  The field was probably cleared for pasture sometime between 1850 and 1900 and used to graze sheep and cattle until about 1950.  The relative size of the apple tree and its neighbour the misshapen oak lead me to believe that it was planted in the shade of the oak while there were still livestock wandering in the field.  This almost definitely wasn’t part of a larger orchard–there are a few other apple trees in this and the next field over but they’re no more dense than a tree for every three acres.  If we want to conjure the pleasant image of a farmer taking a break from the midday sun in the shade of an oak tree for a lunch that draws to a conclusion when he casually discards an apple core that will grow to become this tree we have to ignore the fact that this is probably not possible.

Plant genetics is not one of my areas of expertise but my rough understanding is that because of their long history of cultivation an apple tree will not “breed true”.  In other words, the tree that grows from a random apple seed will have an overwhelming likelihood to revert to the crab apple characteristics that make up the majority of its gene pool.  The cultivated apple varieties, like Red Delicious, are not grown by planting a Red Delicious seed but rather by grafting a Red Delicious bud or shoot onto an existing root stock.

Notice the russeting on these apples that otherwise look like small Mcintoshes

Notice the russeting on these apples that otherwise look like small Mcintoshes

The question of its history aside, this tree puts out some pretty remarkable fruit.  The skin has a Mcintosh-like combination of red and green but the apples are about 70% the size of a grocery store Mcintosh.  The flavour is on the tart side when ripe.  Most interesting is the amount of russeting that these apples get.  Apparently this is an undesirable quality for modern commercial growers because it interrupts the expected colours and indicates a more complex, tart flavour that was traditionally valued more for cider apples than table apples.  Typically I’m happy to find any produce that can boast an heritage or heirloom quality.  Hopefully, September will bring enough sunny days that if I come back before Thanksgiving these apples will be ripe enough to be picked for a skin-on apple sauce.

Ripe apples in pretty hard to reach places

Ripe apples in pretty hard to reach places

We also have neighbours at the cottage who find that the wasps demolish their apples before they can come anywhere near to eating them all.  Given this surplus they are kind enough to share the apples with the rest of us.  Two of their trees were ready to harvest last weekend so a couple of my cousins and I gleaned a bag ful of excellent pink-hued apples.

Apples from the neighbours trees that will become apple pie

Apples from the neighbour's trees that will become apple pie

If anyone can tell from the pictures what variety this is I’d love to know.  On the skin the red parts have a definite pink tone while the green parts tend towards a bit of yellow.  The flesh is bright white and crisp (closer to Granny Smith than Red Delicious).  The balanced sweet-tart flavour is good for eating out of hand but these apples made an excellent apple pie that didn’t need added lemon juice.  Here’s a sneak peek but I’ll have a full post later on about this skillet apple pie.

A sneak peek look at the skillet apple pie

A preview of the skillet apple pie that will get its own post later in the week

Similar Posts:

    None Found

Share this post: More Food With Legs:
Posted in: Foraging.


  1. mochapj says:

    Sounds like you might have some pink lady apples to me; a somewhat blurry photo can be found here:

  2. foodwithlegs says:

    Thanks, PJ. My first guess was also Pink Lady but it looks from this page: like that is probably not the case for two reasons:

    1. It looks like Pink Lady tree stock is pretty tightly controlled by commercial growers. Our neighbours only have two trees and don’t have any connection to the apple biz.

    2. According to the site I linked “Pink Lady requires a very long growing period and a hot climate, and hence is only grown in the warmer apple-growing regions of South Africa, USA, southern Europe – and of course Australia.” Our cottage at 44.4 degrees N is ruled out geographically and these apples were ripe by August 22nd so that doesn’t fit the article’s statement that “Pink Lady apples from the northern hemisphere tend to arrive in shops from late November”.

    As I say, it was also my first guess. Maybe one of Pink Lady’s genetic predecessors.

  3. foodwithlegs says:

    As a further update my mother is sure that these trees are at least 60 to 70 years old so definitely not Pink Lady because it was developed in the 1970s. And since they aren’t Mcintoshes or another long-standing mainstream variety they are probably an heritage variety that will be tough to identify.

  4. [...] pie was made from the apples we picked from a neighbour’s apple tree at the cottage.  These heirloom apples (of unknown variety, see the comment section of the first [...]

  5. [...] over the past month knows that I like apples.  I have posted stories about: discovering a wild apple tree; a recipe for skillet apple pie; the deep-fried apple beignets I made for Labour Day; and a spiced [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>