Food With Legs Rotating Header Image

Deep-Fried Pickles

Deep-fried dill pickles.  Next time Ill work on finding some takeout containers for presentation.

Deep-fried dill pickles. Next time I'll work on finding some takeout containers for presentation.

For Christmas two years ago Alex–my cousin, neighbour at the cottage, and fellow amateur cook–and I were given a turkey deep fryer rig.  We had it out once last summer for a rainbow of fried experiments–mozzarrella sticks, sweet potato tempura, shrimp, chicken wings, and probably a couple more that I am forgetting about.  We decided this year that it is time to get closer to the original purpose of the fryer and fry some whole poultry.  The chickens were great (and will be featured in an upcoming post) but if you’re going to the trouble of setting up the deep fryer and heating all of that oil you also want to fry an appetizer and a dessert.  Happily, my absolute favourite fried starter, deep-fried pickles, are  relatively difficult to find done well in bars or restaurants so make an ideal at-home experiment. These are not quite as over-the-top as deep-fried Mars bars (at heart pickles are vegetables after all) but still very decadent.

The coated pickle spears wait to hit the oil.

The coated pickle spears wait to hit the oil.

I didn’t have to go far to find a recipe.  Alton Brown, my favourite and first Food Network influence, has what looks like a winner.  On the Food Network website a commentor actually complained about Alton Brown’s recipe because, he felt, the pickles contribute too much of the finished product’s flavour!  Seriously.  This, to me, was the clincher for using this recipe.  I’d much rather taste a garlicky, kosher dill pickle that is complemented by a slightly salty, hot coating than deep-fried cornflakes (or some other such nonsense) with only a bare hint of pickle.

This weekend I started another batch of wild pickles so I didn’t feel any qualms about slicing up the first batch’s second-to-last litre of homemade dill pickles for this recipe.   I’m pleased to see that between sharing some with neighbours and their sudden popularity we have managed to run through about eight litres in less than a month.

Each spear went from buttermilk to cornmeal, back to buttermilk and then the cornmeal again.

Each spear went from buttermilk to cornmeal, back to buttermilk and then the cornmeal again.

This time was the first that I have used buttermilk and cornmeal for deep frying.  The more common flour-egg-bread crumb formula yields a delicious breading but the proteins in the egg that do so well to hold onto the bread crumbs also keep the coating distinct from what’s inside.  Often a fried food’s shape (onion rings) or size (shrimp) eliminates the scenario where the hot food falls back onto the plate and leaves the eater holding just an empty shell.  Because fried dill pickles are much too casual for a knife and fork but also too big for one bite this disappointing separation of filling and crust happens much too often.  That’s not the case with the buttermilk and cornmeal, though.  I still give a slight edge for taste to the breadcrumbs but the better crunch and tendency to stay on the pickle makes the cornmeal my overall favourite.

Twelve litres of bubbling hot canola oil is an ideal (and hypo-allergenic) cooking medium.

Twelve litres of bubbling hot canola oil is an ideal (and hypo-allergenic) cooking medium.

I’m pleased to report that the Food Network’s commentor was right–the pickles take centre stage here.  Almost immediately after hitting the hot oil the backyard filled with the pleasant aroma of dill (ironic because the deep fryer was setup in the shadow of the garden’s giant dill plants), garlic and a the familiar, faint sourness.  To me so much of a dill pickle’s savour comes from its cool temperature.  Nothing contrasts better with a hot burger than a bite of cold dill pickle.  But here they are hot and different flavours are emphasised, but I still really like it.  The homemade flavour is also more pronounced.  I thought of describing it as slightly gamey but that isn’t appropriate.  It’s the wildness, the unusual sour flavour–so different from the one note of commerical vinegar–that comes with naturally cured pickles.  With a beer and some blue cheese dipping sauce this was the perfect opening scene for our Labour Day Fry Fest.

Similar Posts:

    None Found

Share this post: More Food With Legs:
Posted in: Entertaining, Frying.


  1. My lips are puckering just at the thought of biting into one. These look great, David! Salty, sour, and crunchy –it doesn’t get much better than that.

  2. foodwithlegs says:

    Thanks, Susan. No it definitely doesn’t get much better.

  3. [...] at the cottage we hosted a party for friends and family that featured a mostly deep-fried menu.  Pickles started the show and warmed up the crowd for the deep-fried whole [...]

  4. [...] They seem like the kind of thing that would go just as excellently with a dinner featuring fried dill pickles and fried whole chickens as they do with a steak.  They’re also one of the few deep fried [...]

  5. [...] be my most frequent topic for posts. I’ve veered from strictly mainstream with posts about deep-frying pickles and making Jello shooters from the brine (seriously) but in 2009 I also did a background post on my [...]

  6. [...] at deep-fried pickles. To see how Alton Brown’s cornmeal-crusted ones turned out for me see this post. And if making pickles is your thing you’ll want to see my recipe for wild (a.k.a. [...]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>